Use of flipchart and powerpoint slide in facilitation

I was volunteered myself to do my first facilitation record on the day 1 of our C6 FAL on 3 August 2013 of our DACE. I was prepared for it even though it was too early and before I could  pick some effective skill  from Mrs Constance Lee.

I did a 15 minutes session in 17 min which was not bad in my presentation/facilitation skill. I have prepared Power point slides, flip chart and some life jackets for my leaners to have an experience. Unfortunately at the end of my 17 min facilitation, I was shocked to realize that I did not use my flip chart which was prepared to display.

I had a shock to discover from the learner’s guide and lecturer  that Adult Educators must use flipchart and powerpoint slides in facilitating adult learning. Is it really important to use both Flipchart and Powerpoint Slides in facilitating adult learning ?

As per assessment criteria we were given the impression that we would be graded ‘NYC’ (No Yet Competent) if we failed to use both of these training aids in facilitating adult learning.

I saw a lot of discussion on this matter on Facebook. The discussion revolved around the ‘seemingly mandatory’ requirements against the backdrop of increasingly complexity of current level of technology, changing demographic profile of the learners, learners’ expectations as well as learning styles.

Should I conclude my previous training session with navy is failures as per this new set of adult Learning concept?   I had never used flipchart and power point slides in experiential activities in my outdoor training sessions, especially boat work or deck work.  

Does it mean that I was not effective in facilitating adult learning then ? I agree that I could had been increasingly effective using flipchart when I conducted outdoor activities for adult learners.  In my view, it would be technically feasible to bring along a flipchart for outdoor experiential activities though it would require additional resources and time.

I think I would be asking myself two questions if I had to conduct outdoor experiential learning activities in future: could I and would I bring along flipchart and powerpoint slides ?, what other tools would help me facilitate adult learning as equally well as flipchart and powerpoint slides ?

I am determined to use flip chart as well as powerpoint slides in my second session which I should restrict in to 13 minutes .